NFL Week 1 Deep Dive: The Coaching Strategy Breakdown For Dan Campbell
Keys To The Game Kicks Off With A Deep Dive-History Is A Great Place To Start When Trying To Understand A Rivalry Through Coaching Tendencies
As the Detroit Lions and Green Bay Packers prepare to clash in Week 1 of the 2025 NFL season, much has already been written about player matchups, roster strengths, and game predictions. Yet, the chess match that defines this divisional rivalry often comes down to the sideline—where head coaches Dan Campbell and Matt LaFleur reveal their true value.
Over the past two seasons, both coaches have shaped their squads through distinct tactical philosophies, risk profiles, and in-game decision-making processes. By examining their respective coaching tendencies, play-calling styles, approaches to critical moments like fourth downs, risk tolerances, willingness to adapt, and head-to-head adjustments, we gain a nuanced understanding of how this high-stakes opener might be called from the top down, influencing the outcome at Lambeau Field on Sunday.
You Can Read The Matt LaFleur Version Here
Dan Campbell: Philosophy, Tendencies, and Strategic Evolution
Coaching Tendencies and Risk Tolerance
Dan Campbell has redefined Detroit’s identity since his 2021 appointment, imprinting the team with a fearless, blue-collar approach built on aggressive risk tolerance and a “no excuses” ethos. His now-legendary introductory speech (the “kneecap” presser) became both a mission statement for the team and a prophecy of how he would coach: “We’re going to kick you in the teeth... and on the way up, we’re going to bite a kneecap off”.
Under Campbell, the Lions have consistently ranked at or near the top of the NFL in fourth-down attempts and overall aggressiveness. From 2021 to 2024, Detroit led the league with 133 fourth-down attempts, converting 52.6%—a success rate that is middle-of-the-pack for volume users, but fourth among teams with 100+ tries. In pure volume and frequency, however, Campbell’s “Dan Gamble” persona is unmatched: Detroit attempted a fourth-down conversion on 34% of offensive drives, highest since 2000.
Campbell’s willingness to deploy these risks even in his own territory—sometimes in situations where analytics recommend caution—has been both celebrated and criticized. His belief in the psychological impact of daring decisions (boosting his team’s confidence, demoralizing defenses) sometimes outweighs analytical conservatism. Indeed, he has encouraged fans to metaphorically “wear a diaper” for games, a nod to how nerve-wracking his decisions can be.
Offensive Play-Calling Style
Offensively, Campbell’s teams have been bold, creative, and frequently unorthodox, especially under former offensive coordinator Ben Johnson. But with Johnson now in Chicago, assistant John Morton has elevated to OC, with Campbell emphasizing that “it’s a Detroit Lions offense” shaped by both personnel and a robust infrastructure.
Creativity, heavy reliance on play-action, pre-snap motion, and well-timed gadget plays are staples of Campbell’s approach. In key victories, he has broken tendency and surprised opponents with trick plays such as fake punts and even tackle-eligible passes, as demonstrated in the 2022 win over the Vikings, or the Cowboys 2pt conversion attempt in 2023.
The run game—featuring talented backs like Jahmyr Gibbs and David Montgomery—remains a foundation, but the willingness to let Jared Goff attack vertically and trust offensive linemen in tough situations is evidence of Campbell’s “trust your guys” mantra.
Campbell is not a “scheme dictator”—he molds the offense around quarterback Goff’s comfort and strengths, while empowering the OC/QB to make real-time checks and adjustments. This flexibility accelerated as the offense matured; Goff was praised in 2025 for proactively suggesting adjustments at the line and in the playbook.
Defensive Play-Calling Style
While Campbell delegates defensive play-calling to his coordinator (Aaron Glenn through 2024, now Kelvin Sheppard in 2025), his fingerprints are visible in the defense’s “attack, don’t absorb” ethos. Over recent seasons, the Lions have restructured their front to play more aggressively “on the opponent’s side of the line of scrimmage,” aiming to penetrate and disrupt rather than passively read and react.
This philosophical shift to an “attacking front” was not just about scheme, but about maximizing individual talents—especially edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson and versatile linemen like Alim McNeill. Campbell’s emphasis on aggressiveness did yield improvements in pressuring quarterbacks and generating turnovers, even as the Lions made adjustments for injuries and personnel changes.
Despite experiencing major setbacks—such as Hutchinson’s season-ending injury in 2024—Campbell’s faith in his staff and the next-man-up mentality fostered a culture of adaptability. As he pointed out, “We’ve been coaching here for four years and [Glenn, now Sheppard] has done everything in his power to work around any personnel we have, and use the players we have, and get the most production we can”.
Defensively, the Lions tend to blitz selectively (41.5% blitz rate in 2023) and focus heavily on ball disruption and creating confusion with rotations and checks.
Fourth-Down Decision-Making
As detailed, Campbell’s willingness to “go for it” is second to none—even when it means following his gut over analytics. Detroit led the NFL with 133 fourth-down attempts over the last four seasons, including 40 in 2023 alone with a 52.5% conversion rate.
But Campbell’s approach is not simply “always aggressive.” He has shown the ability to self-scout and pull back the throttle when he believes it serves the team’s interest. For instance, in the back half of 2022, with Detroit at 1-6, Campbell temporarily shifted to more clock control and ball-security to stabilize the team, “backing things down significantly,” before ramping up aggression during winning streaks.
Perhaps the most scrutinized of his bold decisions came after the 2023 NFC Championship, when two unsuccessful fourth-down calls on the opponent’s side of the field flipped the momentum to the 49ers. Analytics models suggested both situations were effectively coin-flips, slightly favoring aggression, but Campbell drew heat for “leaving six points off the board” in a close defeat.
Yet, Campbell defended his stance, stating, “I’m always gonna lean on the strength of our team,” and that results (drops, fumbles) sometimes distort the process behind the decision.
In-Game Adjustments
A hallmark of Campbell’s leadership is responsibility and accountability for errors. When the Lions were penalized for too many men on the field after a failed clock management attempt at the end of a half in 2024, Campbell faced reporters and took full blame, explaining both the rationale and the lessons learned—inspiring players like Goff to echo that accountability publicly.
Game flow adjustments are regular—Campbell is unafraid to modify tempo, shift from pass-heavy to run-heavy, or lean on special teams trickery to capture momentum. The Lions notably changed their defensive front to facilitate a more attacking style when initial strategies stalled. On offense, Campbell’s collaboration with his coordinators is ongoing during games, where he actively invites and accepts gameplan input.
Analysts note that this adaptability—blending “gut feel” with in-game analytics, and putting ego aside to do what’
Strategic Evolution: 2023–2025
Campbell’s evolution is visible in both macro- and micro-level decisions. Where he once “pushed the envelope” relentlessly, accumulating both praise for his courage and critics for “recklessness,” in 2024 and 2025 he has shown a greater willingness to blend analytics and situational football. This evolution is not a retreat, but rather a demonstration of maturity—remaining aggressive when probabilities favor it, but with better appreciation for game context, roster health, and flow.
Campbell’s adaptability was vividly displayed after the departures of both coordinators in 2025—rather than panic hiring, he “took his time and did it right,” emphasizing chemistry and buy-in for the next phase of the Lions’ culture. At the same time, he’s careful to maintain the identity of “relentless effort and belief,” mirroring the city’s underdog resilience and pushing the franchise to its deepest roster in decades.
Head-to-Head vs. LaFleur’s Packers, 2023–2024
The recent head-to-heads have trended in Campbell’s favor: Detroit has won six of the past seven meetings against Green Bay, including three straight at Lambeau Field. These victories have often hinged on Campbell’s willingness to out-aggress LaFleur—sustaining drives with fourth-down conversions, unleashing creative wrinkles, and outmaneuvering the Packers through bold in-game adjustments.
In their Week 14 2024 matchup, Campbell’s decision to go for it on fourth-and-one in the red zone—eschewing the chip-shot field goal—enabled Detroit to control the clock and ultimately win after a five-attempt, four-conversion day on fourth down.
Analyst Perspectives and Insights
Analysts universally recognize Campbell’s risk tolerance and clutch aggression as narrative-defining traits for Detroit. Eric Woodyard (ESPN) highlights that “Campbell’s bold philosophy remains the backbone of Detroit’s identity, a mindset forged through preparation and unwavering trust in his coaches and players,” with the team all-in on his approach.
Christian Booher (SI.com) notes that although Campbell’s “aggression has come back to bite the Lions at points,” his openness to adjustment—for instance, slowing things down late in the 2022 season—reflects “thorough self-scout and evaluation,” leveraging what he “believes is the best way to play the game and it’s going to help us win”.
Other analysts, such as Brad Berreman (FanSided), break down his most contentious calls with precision—leaving aside “hindsight analysis,” they note Campbell generally follows analytics when evidence supports going for it, though sometimes he misreads situational nuance (as in the 2023 NFC title game).
Importantly, Campbell receives outsized praise not merely for play-calling, but for culture-building. Across social platforms such as Reddit and journalistic outlets, the consensus is that “Campbell is THE DETROIT LIONS,” instilling belief and resilience in a franchise long mired in futility.
Full Steam Ahead To Green Bay!
Dan Campbell’ coaching identity is built on grit, aggression, and calculated risk. Since taking over in Detroit, he’s transformed the Lions from a rebuilding franchise into a legitimate NFC powerhouse. His fourth-down philosophy isn’t just bold—it’s systematic. Detroit led the league in fourth-down attempts last season, converting over 52% of them, often in high-leverage situations. Campbell doesn’t wait for the game to come to him; he forces opponents to respond to his tempo, his physicality, and his trust in his players.
This week’s matchup against Green Bay is a continuation of that mindset. Campbell has beaten LaFleur in three straight meetings, each time leaning into aggressive play-calling and defensive disruption. Expect Detroit to test Green Bay’s young secondary early, especially with Jared Goff’s quick-release timing and the Lions’ deep route tree. On defense, Campbell’s unit will likely stack the box and dare Jordan Love to beat them over the top—a strategy that’s worked in past matchups.
With a revamped offensive line and a healthy front seven, Campbell has the tools to control the trenches and dictate the pace. His coaching style thrives in games like this—divisional, physical, and high-stakes. If the Lions jump out early, don’t expect Campbell to ease off the gas. He’s not just playing to win; he’s playing to dominate.
In a league where many coaches play not to lose, Dan Campbell plays to impose his will. And against a Packers team still searching for its identity, that could be the difference between a Week 1 win and a statement of NFC North supremacy.
Key Strategic Metrics (2023 Season)
Key Strategic Metrics (2024 Season)
All coaching metrics and team statistics were compiled using publicly available data from Pro Football Reference, ESPN Stats & Info, NFL Next Gen Stats, StatMuse, and Sharp Football Analysis. Metrics reflect regular season performance unless otherwise noted.
Join The Detroit Football Journal Daily Podcasts Below
STAY IN THE GAME WITH DETROIT FOOTBALL JOURNAL
The NFC North's Top Ranked Quarterback Is Once Again Jared Goff - It's Not Close
Every season Rocked On Sports Media performs an unbiased review for all positional groups within the NFC North. Grading, analyzing and ranking each positional group from one (1) being the best, and four (4) being the worst.
